“ Every time we visit NYC this is a must stop. The history is rich throughout the floors, pictures and turkey wishbones. They offer only 2 drink options- light or dark. You will be served 2 small mugs when you order each. They offer a few menu items but if you want to go old school order the cheese & crackers. It's a sleeve of saltines, sliced cheese, raw white onions and spicy mustard. ”

“ We talk about McSoreleys at least once a week. We loved it. While on a NY visit we stumbled into this place and we absolutely loved it. It's not fancy, it's not a 5 star food place, it's just a full blown culture bomb. It's dark, a little draby, but so much fun. Everyone is incredible friendly and the vibe is just unmatched. No frills. You get light or dark beer (2 per order so you can do 1ea). Yes, that's your drink menu and you'll love it. They also have a very small classic food menu. I really can't explain the vibe, it's almost like something out of a movie. Everyone is happy, it's loud, it's fun, just come see for yourself. This was our favorite stop overall during our 8 day trip to the city. A legendary historic bar. Thanks again for a great time! ”

“ Great historic bar! Loved learning about how Abe Lincoln patronized this bar and how it survived through the prohibition period. The interior is interesting with all the knick knacks and decor. The only serve 2 ales: light or dark. Dark was delicious. Servers are legit Irish. ”

“ A part of New York City history that's irreplaceable. Authentic, simple, and honest. I always get one of their turkey or ham and cheese sandwiches because the mustard has a horseradish kick that can bring a tear to your eye. Good service and a rustic, old NYC atmosphere is what McSorleys delivers consistently. ”

“ Legendary historic pub with unparalleled vintage charm. Wooden floors, vintage memorabilia, and an authentic Irish pub feel that transports you back in time. Rustic, unpretentious environment with walls covered in historic photographs and artifacts. Oldest Irish tavern in NYC (established 1854) Classic no-frills, no-nonsense service. Bartenders are efficient and knowledgeable about the pub's rich history. Expect straightforward interaction without excessive small talk. Drinks: Only two beer options: light and dark house ale Affordable prices Cash only Traditional Irish pub drinking experience A must-visit for history buffs, beer enthusiasts, and those seeking an authentic NYC pub experience. ”

“ Dropped in with my gal and it's just the same as last time we.wre here months ago which is a good thing. Never change the old items, memorabilia on the walls, sawdust on the floor, choice of light or dark beers in small mugs. A classic. ”

“ This bar is the most no frills bar I've ever seen. They seat you at communal style tables so get ready to make some friends! The waiter asked us "what do you want to drink?" And I said "oh do you have a menu" and he said "yeah, we have dark ale or light ale. End of menu." So if you're wanting a liquor drink or glass of wine, this is not the spot for you. ”

“ What's not to like? Simple, dark or light? Two? Four? Six? How many??? My husband and daughter have been here a few times, this was a first for me. Brandon made our experience even more fun, since we were able to get a table in the back room along with a frat party from Columbia. The "kids" 21+ were having a great time, and I felt young again, listening to them sing. At my table, we offered a seat to a young man "stranger" and chatted with him. Very interesting. We returned the following day for lunch and few more beers. I will definitely come back in the future since we live in the city. ”

“ Part of a self driven historic tour of historic bars in lower Manhattan McSorley is a must stop. Built in the lady 1800s. This establish was male only until the 1970s when the feminist movement encouraged (?) them to open the doors for everybody. The original bar hasn't changed and the front doors are worn from centuries of use. The women's Braziers that once decorated the ceilings are long gone. The men's room only has been modified to provide separate bathrooms for men and women. The historic postings on the wall are worthy of a read, and you must have a one of their cold ales, light or dark, served the same as they've always offered since the day the doors opened for only a few dollars each. It's not fancy, it's just a slice of history and it's awesome. This is a cash only business so make sure you have enough to tip your bartender! I just love this place and you will too. Check out McSorley's. ”